By Colby Sledge
Shelterforce
During uncertain budget times, new revenue sources can be appealing, especially as they can be allocated to policy priorities without the usual political concerns of taking from one bucket to fill another. As political pressure to find sources of tax revenue for affordable housing increases, many communities are turning to so-called sin taxes: a subset of excise taxes designed to raise revenue and, in theory, discourage the use of harmful substances (or harmful conduct) by taxing it more heavily.
Despite the obvious appeal, sin taxes also have disadvantages. For one, the more the tax succeeds in reducing the “sinful” activity, the less tax revenue it raises.
Sin taxes, like sales taxes more generally, are also taxes on consumption. This means that, except for taxes on luxury goods, most sin taxes are regressive, costing people of modest means a greater share of their income than they cost the wealthy. In other words, funding affordable housing through sin taxes burdens a similar population as those who need that housing.
Nonetheless, the need for new housing funds and the advent of new technologies that could be taxed have led many communities to explore this path, and they have some lessons to teach other places that might be looking to do the same. The examples below include three new types of sin taxes—on data centers, on Airbnb-type rental income, and on recreational marijuana—as well as a redirection of existing gaming revenues to affordable housing.