By Izzy Woodruff
South Lake Tahoe, Calif., has long been known for its beaches, parks, resorts and entertainment. Now—thanks to a public-private partnership between Grounded Solutions Network member St. Joseph Community Land Trust and Related California—the city is also known for an intentionally planned, high-quality affordable housing community that will become home to hundreds of families.
The emerging neighborhood, known as Sugar Pine Village, consists of 248 units on 10 acres of public land with access to transit and within walking distance of a grocery store and pharmacy. It was the first competitively awarded site made available under Governor Gavin Newsom’s executive order to open state lands for affordable housing development, and it is the largest affordable housing project in South Lake Tahoe’s history.
The Golden Opportunity
The decision to jointly pursue this competitive development opportunity came naturally to for-profit Related California and non-profit St. Joseph CLT who both saw several very clear mutual benefits to working together.
“We’re a small nonprofit with a very small staff. There’s no way we could do a project like this alone,” said Jean Diaz, Saint Joseph CLT’s Executive Director. “We felt that Related was the most logical partner for us given their experience and capacity.”
The Related Companies—including Related California—manage more than 55,000 affordable residences throughout the country.
For its part, Related was keenly aware of the importance of St. Joseph’s established relationships within the South Lake Tahoe community and City government.
“Finding a local partner is important to us because there is that local expertise in knowing what the community needs. That’s a big decision for us. The partnership has been very successful and is a model for other developers and community land trusts,” said Nathanial Hanson, Related California’s Manager of Real Estate Development and Government Affairs.
A Dream Scenario
The strong relationship between Related and St. Joseph was a significant determinant in the success of the Sugar Pine Village project but there were several other crucial factors that helped move things along.
“This project was lucky to have a strong partner in the City of South Lake Tahoe that provided funding, and we were very lucky that the Tahoe Regional Planning Agency was supportive,” Hanson said. “We are also lucky to have the support of the County. This is the story of intergovernmental participation.”
Another key component was California’s passage of SB 35 in 2017, a law that allows for by-right approval—a much more streamlined approval process—of affordable housing projects that meet certain criteria.
“SB 35 is a revolutionary tool for entitling affordable housing in California,” Hanson said. “The entitlement of the entire project took six months. Without SB 35 and other favorable factors, this could have been a five-to-six-year project, if it succeeded at all.”
Because Tahoe is surrounded by mountains — the Sierra Nevada mountains to the west and the Carson range to the east — construction is strictly prohibited from October to May each year to prevent runoff.
“The phasing was due to the construction timeline and also because of the financing environment that we had to work our way through,” Hanson said. “The first two phases had set-aside funding from the state, and then the City of South Lake Tahoe also provided funding.”
Sugar Pine’s first two phases have already been completed. Phase III, currently underway, will be completed later this year. And the final phase is in predevelopment.

To help account for Tahoe’s limited window for construction each year, the team utilized modular construction, a still relatively new method through which units are assembled in a factory offsite and then shipped to the construction site and stacked up. It has a lot of potential to decrease costs and timeline.
“Modular was a really important piece of this project, and it is a particularly good solution for areas that have condensed building seasons,” Hanson said. “This is a project that you walk in and you have no idea that it was built in a factory.”
Blueprint for Success
Diaz and Hanson have some advice for other organizations looking to replicate what St. Joseph and Related accomplished in Tahoe.
“It was a very rare opportunity,” Diaz said, noting that although there are opportunities to do smaller scale projects, there aren’t very many large parcels of land in the basin. “Engaging in a large-scale project like this is not suitable to all community land trusts. It makes sense for the right kind of community land trust. We were able to bring the tax exemption. We were able to leverage our local contacts and provide local oversight to management, and we provide local services to the tenants,” he added.
Diaz also noted that, for St. Joseph, participating in a project like Sugar Pine Village has been an important way to generate revenue that supports its various affordable housing-related programs.
Hanson stressed the importance of working with architects and contractors who have extensive experience with modular and affordable housing.
“A lot of people talk about affordable housing, but to actually do affordable housing is hard, and it takes a lot of people,” Hanson said. “It’s important to have community relationships and technical knowledge, and you also need public partners that understand those two things. If you don’t have all those pieces, it’s going to be very challenging.”
Then there’s the issue of navigating sometimes byzantine regulatory and tax frameworks to ensure properties maintain lasting affordability.
“With tax credit projects there’s a 15-year compliance period during which the properties must stay affordable. In certain situations, a project can become a market-rate project. That is usually the time that we will re-syndicate and apply for additional tax credits so that we can rehab the property and then reset the 15-year period,” Hanson said. “We are committed to long-term ownership.”
“Some developers are just into this project for the initial 15-year period, but we like the fact that Related is in for the long haul,” Diaz said.
Visit https://sugarpinevillageslt.com/ to learn more about the project.
Izzy Woodruff is the Communications Director for Grounded Solutions Network.